How to Share Difficult News With Donors (Without Losing Trust)

There’s a lot changing right now.

We’re hearing it in nearly every conversation with nonprofit leaders:

Federal funding cuts that mean you need to raise more from the community.

Programs shifting. Staff adapting.

Clients being served differently—sometimes virtually, sometimes with added safety concerns.

Foundation and corporate partners pulling back—or no longer aligned with your values.

Costs rising.

So. Much. Uncertainty.

And alongside all of that, there’s a quieter question sitting underneath:

How do we talk about this with our donors?

The Fear Is Real

It can feel risky to say what’s really going on. You might worry that:

• You’ll sound unstable

• You’ll erode confidence

• You’ll be seen as struggling or failing

• You’ll “air dirty laundry”

So the instinct is to soften it.

To wait.

To share only part of the story.

But here’s what we want to offer:

Your donors don’t need protection from the truth.

Donors Want to Know

Your donors care about your mission. They want to understand:

• What’s happening

• What it means

• What it will take to keep going

• How they can be part of sustaining the work

When you don’t share what’s really happening, you don’t preserve trust.

You limit it. Because people can’t step into a need they don’t understand.

Sharing difficult news isn’t a risk to your fundraising.It’s an invitation into deeper partnership.

You Don’t Have to Have It All Figured Out

One of the biggest blockers we see: “I don’t want to say anything until we know more.”

But your donors don’t need a finished story.

They can handle:

• “We don’t know yet.”

• “We’re still figuring this out.”

• “Here’s what we’re seeing right now.”

In fact, those moments—when things are still unfolding—are often when people feel most connected and ready to help.

Waiting for certainty often means waiting too long.

What Values-Based Communication Looks Like

If you’re going to share difficult news, how you do it matters. Here are a few ways to do it in a values-based way.

1. Be authentic

Say it in your voice. Not the polished, corporate version.

Instead of:

“We are navigating a dynamic external environment…”

Try:

“We want to be honest with you about what we’re navigating right now.”

or

“This is a harder update to write than usual, but it feels important to share it with you.”

2. Center your values

Don’t just share what’s happening. Share how you’re making decisions.

Try:

“Our commitment to [your values] is guiding every decision we’re making—even when those decisions are hard.”

or

“We’re choosing this path because it aligns with our values, even though it comes with trade-offs.”

Values give people something to anchor to when circumstances are shifting.

3. Be as transparent as possible

Clarity builds trust.

Instead of:

“We’re experiencing some financial challenges…”

Try:

“Due to federal funding cuts, we’re facing a $250,000 gap this year.”

Be transparent about the wins, too.

“At the same time, we’ve expanded evening hours—something our community has been asking for.”

People can hold complexity. Let them.

4. Use plain language

Simple, clear language is more trustworthy than vague or technical phrasing.

Try:

“We don’t have enough funding right now to meet the growing need.”

or

“More people are coming to us for help, and it’s costing more to serve them.”

5. Name what you don’t know

You don’t need to have all the answers.

Try:

“We don’t yet know how long these funding changes will last.”

“We’re still figuring out what this will mean for our programs over the next year.”

Honesty about uncertainty builds credibility—not the opposite.

6. Share your gap

Be clear about what it will take to continue your work.

Try:

“It will take $1.2 million from our community to sustain this work this year.”

When people understand the gap, they’re more prepared to give, act, and advocate.

7. Offer ways to act

Don’t stop at information. Invite participation.

Yes, that may include giving. But it can also include:

Try:

“If you’re able to make a gift, now is a critical time.”

“We’re also looking for volunteers to help create a sense of safety in our space.”

“Would you be willing to contact your legislator about this issue?”

When people know how to help, they’re far more likely to do something.

8. Bring your staff along

Before you share difficult news externally, make sure your team knows.

Try (internally):

“We’re planning to share this with donors next week. Here’s what we’re saying and why. We want you to hear it from us first.”

This builds internal trust and alignment.

This Is How Trust Is Built

When you share difficult news this way, you’re not weakening relationships. You’re strengthening them.

You’re saying:

• We trust you with the truth

• We’re grounded in our values

• We’re committed to this work

• You are part of this community

And that’s what builds long-term support.

Not perfection.Not polished messaging.Not certainty.

Honesty. Clarity. Invitation.

If This Feels Hard, You’re Not Alone

We know this isn’t easy.

Many leaders know exactly what they want to say—but don’t have the time, space, or words to say it clearly.

So the message sits.

Or gets softened.

Or never goes out.

This is one of the ways we support organizations every day.

We take what you’re navigating—funding changes, program shifts, uncertainty—and help turn it into communication you can actually send.

Emails. Appeals. Talking points. Event remarks.

Clear. Honest. Values-aligned.

Because these messages matter. They’re not just updates. They’re invitations into your mission.

If you’re working on something like this and want a thought partner (or someone to draft it with you or for you), we’re here. You don’t have to do it alone.

---

Want more of this kind of help in your inbox about every other week? Sign up for our Community of Care here.